Though Judah fails in sexual integrity, covenant duty, and moral consistency, God exposes His sin through Tamar’s bold action and preserves the line of promise through a shocking reversal that brings forth Perez.
Text Size
Genesis 38
Judah Descends into Corruption, Tamar Secures Justice, and the Line of Promise Moves Forward Through Exposure and Reversal
Though Judah fails in sexual integrity, covenant duty, and moral consistency, God exposes His sin through Tamar’s bold action and preserves the line of promise through a shocking reversal that brings forth Perez.
Reading a chapter
What this page is: Each chapter page shows the big idea, the argument flow, key original-language terms, doctrine connections, and passage units, all in one place.
How to use it: Start with the Overview tab to get the chapter's main point. Then move to Passages to study individual units, or Language to trace key terms.
Going deeper: The Doctrines and Motifs tabs show how this chapter connects to the broader biblical story.
Chapter Summary
Though Judah fails in sexual integrity, covenant duty, and moral consistency, God exposes His sin through Tamar’s bold action and preserves the line of promise through a shocking reversal that brings forth Perez.
Overview
Genesis 38 teaches that God preserves the covenant line through human corruption without approving that corruption, and that His providence may expose hypocrisy and overturn social expectations in order to advance His purpose. Judah begins the chapter by descending relationally, morally, and covenantally. He separates from His brothers, marries into Canaanite society, and builds a household whose first sons are marked by wickedness and death.
Er’s evil and Onan’s calculated refusal to raise up offspring expose the seriousness of covenant-line responsibility. Onan’s sin is not merely sexual misbehavior in the abstract. It is the willful refusal to fulfill familial duty while still exploiting Tamar sexually for His own ends. Judah then compounds the injustice by withholding Shelah from Tamar under the cover of delay and fear.
Tamar is left exposed, childless, and functionally discarded. The turning point comes through Tamar’s risky and morally complex intervention. The narrative does not present her disguise as morally ideal in every respect, yet it decisively vindicates her relative righteousness over Judah’s failure. Judah’s hypocrisy is laid bare when He is ready to execute Tamar publicly for sexual immorality while remaining blind to His own conduct.
The exposure through the pledge items forces confession. His declaration that Tamar is more righteous than He is the theological center of the chapter. This is not because Judah becomes righteous in an absolute sense, but because Tamar acted to secure the offspring and justice Judah refused to provide. The birth scene then seals the chapter’s reversal theme.
Like Jacob over Esau and Perez over Zerah, the one who appears second overtakes the one who seemed first. Thus Genesis 38 argues that God’s covenant line is preserved through judgment on wickedness, exposure of hypocrisy, vindication of the wronged, and reversal of natural expectation. The promise survives not because Judah’s house is morally stable, but because God refuses to let the line perish.
Genesis 38 interrupts the Joseph narrative and turns attention to Judah, one of Joseph’s brothers and one of Jacob’s sons through Leah. This placement is deliberate. After Genesis 37 showed Joseph rejected and sold by His brothers, the narrative pauses Joseph’s descent into Egypt in order to expose what is happening within Judah’s line. Historically within Genesis, the chapter traces Judah’s movement away from His brothers, His marriage into Canaanite society, the deaths of His sons, His failure to uphold family duty toward Tamar, and the shocking reversal through which Tamar secures offspring.
Within the broader patriarchal narrative, the chapter is profoundly important because Judah, not Joseph, carries the royal and messianic trajectory that will later be made explicit in Genesis 49. That means this morally disturbing chapter is not marginal. It is central to the preservation of the line through which kings, and ultimately the Messiah, will come.
The chapter therefore stands at the intersection of sexual ethics, levirate responsibility, covenant line preservation, hypocrisy, judgment, and surprising grace. Its very darkness serves the larger story by showing that the promise continues not because the human line is clean, but because God preserves it through exposure, humiliation, and reversal.
Structural Flow
Judah departs from His brothers, turns aside to an Adullamite named Hirah, marries the daughter of a Canaanite named Shua, and fathers three sons: Er, Onan, and Shelah.
Judah takes Tamar as wife for Er, His firstborn. Er is wicked in the sight of the Lord, and the Lord puts Him to death. Judah then instructs Onan to perform a brother-in-law duty to raise up offspring for His brother, but Onan spills His seed to avoid producing offspring for Er. What He does is evil in the sight of the Lord, and the Lord puts Him to death also. Judah, fearing for Shelah’s life, sends Tamar away to her father’s house as a widow, promising Shelah later but not intending to fulfill it.
After the death of Judah’s wife, Judah goes up to Timnah for sheep-shearing with Hirah. Tamar, seeing that Shelah has grown and she has not been given to Him, disguises herself as a prostitute and sits by the roadside. Judah does not recognize her, goes in to her, and gives her His seal, cord, and staff as pledge until He can send payment. Tamar conceives by Him. Judah later sends the young goat through Hirah, but the woman cannot be found.
About three months later Judah is told Tamar is pregnant by immorality. He orders her to be brought out and burned. As she is brought out, Tamar sends the seal, cord, and staff, declaring that the man to whom these belong is the father. Judah recognizes them and confesses, 'She is more righteous than I, since I did not give her to my son Shelah.' He does not sleep with her again.
Tamar gives birth to twins. Zerah’s hand emerges first and is marked with a scarlet thread, but Perez breaks out first and is born ahead of Him, followed by Zerah.
Chapter Outline
- 38:1–5: Judah departs from His brothers, turns aside to an Adullamite named Hirah, marries the daughter of a Canaanite named Shua, and fathers three sons: Er, Onan, and Shelah.
- 38:6–11: Judah takes Tamar as wife for Er, His firstborn. Er is wicked in the sight of the Lord, and the Lord puts Him to death. Judah then instructs Onan to perform a brother-in-law duty to raise up offspring for His brother, but Onan spills His seed to avoid producing offspring for Er. What He does is evil in the sight of the Lord, and the Lord puts Him to death also. Judah, fearing for Shelah’s life, sends Tamar away to her father’s house as a widow, promising Shelah later but not intending to fulfill it.
- 38:12–23: After the death of Judah’s wife, Judah goes up to Timnah for sheep-shearing with Hirah. Tamar, seeing that Shelah has grown and she has not been given to Him, disguises herself as a prostitute and sits by the roadside. Judah does not recognize her, goes in to her, and gives her His seal, cord, and staff as pledge until He can send payment. Tamar conceives by Him. Judah later sends the young goat through Hirah, but the woman cannot be found.
- 38:24–26: About three months later Judah is told Tamar is pregnant by immorality. He orders her to be brought out and burned. As she is brought out, Tamar sends the seal, cord, and staff, declaring that the man to whom these belong is the father. Judah recognizes them and confesses, 'She is more righteous than I, since I did not give her to my son Shelah.' He does not sleep with her again.
- 38:27–30: Tamar gives birth to twins. Zerah’s hand emerges first and is marked with a scarlet thread, but Perez breaks out first and is born ahead of Him, followed by Zerah.
Theological Focus
- Providence
- Covenant Line Preservation
- Judgment
- Hypocrisy Exposed
- Righteousness by Contrast
- Reversal
- Family Duty
- Grace through Corruption
- Covenant Theology
- Hamartiology
- Sexual Ethics
- Biblical Theology
- Christology Preparation
Covenant Significance
Genesis 38 is covenantally decisive because it preserves the Judah line through Tamar and Perez. This matters immensely because Judah’s line will later emerge as the royal line within Israel. Without the offspring secured here, that future trajectory would be interrupted. The chapter also reinforces that covenant continuity may hang on matters of household faithfulness, inheritance, and offspring, not only on public patriarchal speeches.
The failure of Er, Onan, and Judah places the line at risk, but God overrules their corruption. Perez’s birth becomes the critical covenantal outcome, and later Scripture will treat Him as an important ancestral figure in the messianic genealogy. The chapter therefore functions as a preservation chapter for the line of promise within Judah’s branch.
Canonical Connections
Genesis 38 is covenantally decisive because it preserves the Judah line through Tamar and Perez. This matters immensely because Judah’s line will later emerge as the royal line within Israel. Without the offspring secured here, that future trajectory would be interrupted. The chapter also reinforces that covenant continuity may hang on matters of household faithfulness, inheritance, and offspring, not only on public patriarchal speeches.
The failure of Er, Onan, and Judah places the line at risk, but God overrules their corruption. Perez’s birth becomes the critical covenantal outcome, and later Scripture will treat Him as an important ancestral figure in the messianic genealogy. The chapter therefore functions as a preservation chapter for the line of promise within Judah’s branch.
Genesis 17:1-14
Genesis 49:8-10
Ruth 4:12
1 Chronicles 2:4-5
Deuteronomy 25:5-10
Genesis 37:1-36
Genesis 49:8-10
Ruth 4:12-22
Matthew 1:3
Cross References
Clarifies how the passage points to the gospel of Christ.
Clarifies how the passage points to the gospel of Christ.
Clarifies how the passage points to the gospel of Christ.
Shows Old Testament grounding that frames or supports this passage.
If brothers dwell together, and one of them dies and has no son, the wife of the dead shall not be married outside to a stranger. Her husband’s brother shall go in to her, and take her as his wife, and perform the duty of a husband’s...
Shows Old Testament grounding that frames or supports this passage.
I will bless those who bless you, and I will curse him who treats you with contempt. All the families of the earth will be blessed through you.”
Shows Old Testament grounding that frames or supports this passage.
He who conceals his sins doesn’t prosper, but whoever confesses and renounces them finds mercy.
Shows Old Testament grounding that frames or supports this passage.
Shows Old Testament grounding that frames or supports this passage.
Let your house be like the house of Perez, whom Tamar bore to Judah, of the offspring which Yahweh will give you by this young woman.”
Develops the same theological theme in another location.
Develops the same theological theme in another location.
Develops the same theological theme in another location.
Gospel Clarity
Genesis 38 strengthens the gospel trajectory by showing that the line leading to the Messiah is preserved through scandal, failure, and divine overruling rather than human purity. Judah is exposed. Tamar is vindicated. Perez is born. That means the messianic line advances through a setting no human being would design as noble. This prepares the reader to understand the gospel of grace more deeply.
Jesus Christ comes through a real human history marked by sin and shame, not because He shares that sin, but because God’s saving purpose enters and overcomes human corruption. The chapter therefore magnifies the sovereign grace that guards the line of promise until it reaches its fulfillment in Christ.
Gospel Cross References
Primary Emphasis
Genesis 38 contributes directly to Christology through Perez, who becomes part of the messianic genealogy. The chapter is therefore not merely morally instructive, it is genealogically and redemptively foundational. It also contributes to the theology of grace and reversal, showing that the line leading to Christ passes through scandal, exposure, and morally broken settings.
This does not diminish Christ’s holiness. It magnifies the sovereign grace of God in history. The Messiah does not come from a spotless human chain, but through a line God preserves and governs despite its corruption. Tamar’s place in that story also anticipates the way surprising and socially vulnerable figures are incorporated into the redemptive history that culminates in Christ.
Chapter Contribution
Genesis 38 teaches that God preserves the covenant line through human corruption without approving that corruption, and that His providence may expose hypocrisy and overturn social expectations in order to advance His purpose. Judah begins the chapter by descending relationally, morally, and covenantally. He separates from His brothers, marries into Canaanite society, and builds a household whose first sons are marked by wickedness and death.
Er’s evil and Onan’s calculated refusal to raise up offspring expose the seriousness of covenant-line responsibility. Onan’s sin is not merely sexual misbehavior in the abstract. It is the willful refusal to fulfill familial duty while still exploiting Tamar sexually for His own ends. Judah then compounds the injustice by withholding Shelah from Tamar under the cover of delay and fear.
Tamar is left exposed, childless, and functionally discarded. The turning point comes through Tamar’s risky and morally complex intervention. The narrative does not present her disguise as morally ideal in every respect, yet it decisively vindicates her relative righteousness over Judah’s failure. Judah’s hypocrisy is laid bare when He is ready to execute Tamar publicly for sexual immorality while remaining blind to His own conduct.
The exposure through the pledge items forces confession. His declaration that Tamar is more righteous than He is the theological center of the chapter. This is not because Judah becomes righteous in an absolute sense, but because Tamar acted to secure the offspring and justice Judah refused to provide. The birth scene then seals the chapter’s reversal theme.
Like Jacob over Esau and Perez over Zerah, the one who appears second overtakes the one who seemed first. Thus Genesis 38 argues that God’s covenant line is preserved through judgment on wickedness, exposure of hypocrisy, vindication of the wronged, and reversal of natural expectation. The promise survives not because Judah’s house is morally stable, but because God refuses to let the line perish.
Doctrines in This Chapter
God ensures the continuation of the promised line despite human failure.
God actively judges wickedness, even among those connected to the covenant line.
Moral failure exists even within the covenant family and must be addressed by God.
God preserves His purposes through complex and imperfect human circumstances.
True recognition of sin leads to humility and moral turning, as seen in Judah.
Reading Lenses
5 Imperatives
- Go in to Your brother’s wife and raise up offspring
- Bring her out and let her be burned
- Discern, please, whose these are
- The chapter’s moral force warns against refusing righteous duty and against condemning others while hiding one’s own sin
Key Hebrew Terms
Sense perform brother-in-law duty, marry the widow for offspring
Definition perform brother-in-law duty, marry the widow for offspring
Why it matters The command given to Onan is central to the chapter because covenant-line continuity and justice for Tamar are tied to this refused duty.
Sense seed, offspring
Definition seed, offspring
Why it matters The seed theme is critical here because the chapter turns on the question of raising up offspring and preserving Judah’s line.
Sense waste on the ground, destroy on the earth
Definition waste on the ground, destroy on the earth
Why it matters Onan’s act is narrated as a deliberate refusal to produce offspring for His brother, revealing selfish exploitation rather than faithful covenant duty.
Individual words חַיָּה רָעָה chayyah ra'ah · עֵינֵי הַגּוֹיִם ʿênê haggôyim · וְיָדְעוּ כִּי־אֲנִי יְהוָה wəyāḏəʿû kî-ʾănî YHWH
Sense evil in the sight of the LORD
Definition evil in the sight of the LORD
Why it matters The deaths of Er and Onan are explicitly tied to evil in the sight of the Lord, making divine judgment unmistakably central to the chapter.
Sense cult prostitute / prostitute
Definition cult prostitute / prostitute
Why it matters The shifting terminology heightens the moral confusion of the episode and underscores Judah’s readiness to engage in sexual sin while later condemning Tamar.
Sense seal, signet
Definition seal, signet
Why it matters Judah’s seal becomes the key evidence that exposes Him and forces confession, turning His own identity marker into the instrument of truth.
Sense cord
Definition cord
Why it matters Along with the seal and staff, the cord serves as evidence that strips Judah of denial and brings public moral exposure.
Sense staff
Definition staff
Why it matters Judah’s staff, surrendered in lust, becomes part of the proof that His hidden conduct cannot remain hidden.
Individual words צָדְקָה מִמֶּנִּי tsadeqah mimmeni · הַקָּטֹן יִגְדַּל מִמֶּנּוּ ha-qaton yigdal mimennu
Sense she is more righteous than I
Definition she is more righteous than I
Why it matters Judah’s confession is the theological center of the chapter, acknowledging Tamar’s relative righteousness in contrast to His covenant negligence.
Sense Perez, breach, breakout
Definition Perez, breach, breakout
Why it matters Perez’s birth continues the Genesis motif of reversal and becomes crucial for the royal and messianic genealogy.
Cross-language bridge 1 link · View in lexicon
Sense Zerah, dawning, shining out
Definition Zerah, dawning, shining out
Why it matters Zerah’s briefly emerging hand and scarlet thread heighten the reversal when Perez nevertheless comes out first.
Cross-language bridge 1 link · View in lexicon
Sense scarlet
Definition scarlet
Why it matters The scarlet thread marks the apparent firstborn, only for the narrative to overturn expectation again in Perez’s emergence.
Lexicon data: MorphGNT Strong's Dictionary XML (CC0) · Open Scriptures Hebrew Bible (CC BY 4.0) · Open Scriptures Hebrew Lexicon (CC BY 4.0) · STEPBible Data (CC BY 4.0) · Full details
Commentary (Keil & Delitzsch)
C.F. Keil & F. Delitzsch, Commentary on the Old Testament (1861–91) — public domain
Warnings and Misreadings
- Genesis 38 warns that sexual sin, covenant negligence, and moral hypocrisy invite divine judgment, and that those who refuse righteous responsibility may be publicly exposed by the very people they wronged.
- Treating Onan’s sin as only a narrow private sexual matter while missing that the chapter centers on His refusal to raise up offspring for His brother and His exploitation of Tamar.
- Reading Tamar simply as immoral without reckoning with Judah’s confession that she was more righteous than He because He failed to give her Shelah.
- Assuming the chapter is an unrelated digression from Joseph, when it is strategically placed to establish Judah’s moral condition and preserve the line through which later royal promise will come.
- Flattening Judah’s confession into full spiritual transformation, when the chapter presents real exposure and admission but not yet full maturity.
- Ignoring the significance of Perez’s birth, which is the chapter’s covenantal and genealogical climax.
- Missing the repeated reversal pattern in Genesis, where the expected first is overtaken in the outworking of God’s purpose.
Discipleship Questions
- Where are You tempted to judge publicly what You tolerate privately, as Judah did?
- What responsibilities toward others have You delayed, neglected, or hidden behind excuses while still preserving Your own comfort?
- How does Tamar’s vindication challenge the way You think about the vulnerable, the overlooked, and those trapped by another person’s failure?
- What does this chapter teach You about the seriousness of sexual sin when joined to selfishness, exploitation, and covenant neglect?
- How does Perez’s surprising birth deepen Your trust that God can preserve His purpose through deeply broken circumstances?
Pastoral Applications
- Preach Genesis 38 with moral clarity, naming Judah’s failure, Onan’s selfishness, and Tamar’s wronged position without flattening the complexity of the story.
- Use the chapter to expose hypocrisy, especially the kind that condemns in others what it excuses in oneself.
- Teach that covenant obligations, family responsibilities, and justice toward the vulnerable are not optional matters before God.
- Warn clearly that sexual sin in Scripture is often tied to broader sins of exploitation, deception, and refusal of responsibility.
- Show that God may vindicate the overlooked and humiliate the powerful who use them.
- Use Judah’s confession to call hearers toward honest repentance that begins by naming personal guilt rather than preserving appearances.
- Point to Perez as evidence that God’s redemptive purpose can continue through situations human beings have deeply corrupted, which should humble us and magnify grace.
Pastoral Trajectories
Genesis 38 strengthens the gospel trajectory by showing that the line leading to the Messiah is preserved through scandal, failure, and divine overruling rather than human purity. Judah is exposed. Tamar is vindicated. Perez is born. That means the messianic line advances through a setting no human being would design as noble. This prepares the reader to understand the gospel of grace more deeply.
Jesus Christ comes through a real human history marked by sin and shame, not because He shares that sin, but because God’s saving purpose enters and overcomes human corruption. The chapter therefore magnifies the sovereign grace that guards the line of promise until it reaches its fulfillment in Christ.
Genesis 38 strengthens the gospel trajectory by showing that the line leading to the Messiah is preserved through scandal, failure, and divine overruling rather than human purity. Judah is exposed. Tamar is vindicated. Perez is born. That means the messianic line advances through a setting no human being would design as noble. This prepares the reader to understand the gospel of grace more deeply.
Jesus Christ comes through a real human history marked by sin and shame, not because He shares that sin, but because God’s saving purpose enters and overcomes human corruption. The chapter therefore magnifies the sovereign grace that guards the line of promise until it reaches its fulfillment in Christ.
Genesis 38 strengthens the gospel trajectory by showing that the line leading to the Messiah is preserved through scandal, failure, and divine overruling rather than human purity. Judah is exposed. Tamar is vindicated. Perez is born. That means the messianic line advances through a setting no human being would design as noble. This prepares the reader to understand the gospel of grace more deeply.
Jesus Christ comes through a real human history marked by sin and shame, not because He shares that sin, but because God’s saving purpose enters and overcomes human corruption. The chapter therefore magnifies the sovereign grace that guards the line of promise until it reaches its fulfillment in Christ.
Genesis 38 strengthens the gospel trajectory by showing that the line leading to the Messiah is preserved through scandal, failure, and divine overruling rather than human purity. Judah is exposed. Tamar is vindicated. Perez is born. That means the messianic line advances through a setting no human being would design as noble. This prepares the reader to understand the gospel of grace more deeply.
Jesus Christ comes through a real human history marked by sin and shame, not because He shares that sin, but because God’s saving purpose enters and overcomes human corruption. The chapter therefore magnifies the sovereign grace that guards the line of promise until it reaches its fulfillment in Christ.
Genesis 38 strengthens the gospel trajectory by showing that the line leading to the Messiah is preserved through scandal, failure, and divine overruling rather than human purity. Judah is exposed. Tamar is vindicated. Perez is born. That means the messianic line advances through a setting no human being would design as noble. This prepares the reader to understand the gospel of grace more deeply.
Jesus Christ comes through a real human history marked by sin and shame, not because He shares that sin, but because God’s saving purpose enters and overcomes human corruption. The chapter therefore magnifies the sovereign grace that guards the line of promise until it reaches its fulfillment in Christ.
Imperatives
5
High
Imperative Themes
- Go in to Your brother’s wife and raise up offspring
- Bring her out and let her be burned
- Discern, please, whose these are
- The chapter’s moral force warns against refusing righteous duty and against condemning others while hiding one’s own sin
Motifs in This Chapter
The Biblical World
Chapter At A Glance
Genesis 38 is covenantally decisive because it preserves the Judah line through Tamar and Perez. This matters immensely because Judah’s line will later emerge as the royal line within Israel. Without the offspring secured here, that future trajectory would be interrupted. The chapter also reinforces that covenant continuity may hang on matters of household faithfulness, inheritance, and offspring, not only on public patriarchal speeches.
The failure of Er, Onan, and Judah places the line at risk, but God overrules their corruption. Perez’s birth becomes the critical covenantal outcome, and later Scripture will treat Him as an important ancestral figure in the messianic genealogy. The chapter therefore functions as a preservation chapter for the line of promise within Judah’s branch.
Genesis 38 strengthens the gospel trajectory by showing that the line leading to the Messiah is preserved through scandal, failure, and divine overruling rather than human purity. Judah is exposed. Tamar is vindicated. Perez is born. That means the messianic line advances through a setting no human being would design as noble. This prepares the reader to understand the gospel of grace more deeply.
Jesus Christ comes through a real human history marked by sin and shame, not because He shares that sin, but because God’s saving purpose enters and overcomes human corruption. The chapter therefore magnifies the sovereign grace that guards the line of promise until it reaches its fulfillment in Christ.
Focus Points
- Providence
- Covenant Line Preservation
- Judgment
- Hypocrisy Exposed
- Righteousness by Contrast
- Reversal
- Family Duty
- Grace through Corruption
- Covenant Theology
- Hamartiology
- Sexual Ethics
- Biblical Theology
- Christology Preparation
Cross References
When Abram was ninety-nine years old, Yahweh appeared to Abram and said to Him, “I am God Almighty. Walk before me and be blameless. I will make my covenant between me and You, and will multiply You exceedingly.” Abram fell on His face. God talked with Him, saying,
Old Testament foundation
“Judah, Your brothers will praise You. Your hand will be on the neck of Your enemies. Your father’s sons will bow down before You. Judah is a lion’s cub. From the prey, my son, You have gone up. He stooped down, He crouched as a lion, as a lioness. Who will rouse Him up? The scepter will not depart from Judah, nor the ruler’s staff from between His feet,...
Old Testament foundation
Let Your house be like the house of Perez, whom Tamar bore to Judah, of the offspring which Yahweh will give You by this young woman.”
Old Testament foundation
Tamar His daughter-in-law bore Him Perez and Zerah. All the sons of Judah were five. The sons of Perez: Hezron and Hamul.
Old Testament foundation
If brothers dwell together, and one of them dies and has no son, the wife of the dead shall not be married outside to a stranger. Her husband’s brother shall go in to her, and take her as His wife, and perform the duty of a husband’s brother to her. It shall be that the firstborn whom she bears shall succeed in the name of His brother who is dead, that His...
Old Testament foundation
Judah became the father of Perez and Zerah by Tamar. Perez became the father of Hezron. Hezron became the father of Ram.
Gospel resolution
For all have sinned, and fall short of the glory of God; being justified freely by His grace through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus;
Gospel resolution
For such a high priest was fitting for us: holy, guiltless, undefiled, separated from sinners, and made higher than the heavens;
Gospel resolution
But when they continued asking Him, He looked up and said to them, “He who is without sin among You, let Him throw the first stone at her.” Again He stooped down and wrote on the ground with His finger. They, when they heard it, being convicted by their conscience, went out one by one, beginning from the oldest, even to the last. Jesus was left alone with...
Gospel resolution
But when the fullness of the time came, God sent out His Son, born to a woman, born under the law, that He might redeem those who were under the law, that we might receive the adoption of children.
Gospel resolution
Jacob lived in the land of His father’s travels, in the land of Canaan. This is the history of the generations of Jacob. Joseph, being seventeen years old, was feeding the flock with His brothers. He was a boy with the sons of Bilhah and Zilpah, His father’s wives. Joseph brought an evil report of them to their father. Now Israel loved Joseph more than all...
Thematic parallel
“Judah, Your brothers will praise You. Your hand will be on the neck of Your enemies. Your father’s sons will bow down before You. Judah is a lion’s cub. From the prey, my son, You have gone up. He stooped down, He crouched as a lion, as a lioness. Who will rouse Him up? The scepter will not depart from Judah, nor the ruler’s staff from between His feet,...
Thematic parallel
Let Your house be like the house of Perez, whom Tamar bore to Judah, of the offspring which Yahweh will give You by this young woman.” So Boaz took Ruth and she became His wife; and He went in to her, and Yahweh enabled her to conceive, and she bore a son. The women said to Naomi, “Blessed be Yahweh, who has not left You today without a near kinsman. Let...
Thematic parallel
Judah became the father of Perez and Zerah by Tamar. Perez became the father of Hezron. Hezron became the father of Ram.
Thematic parallel
Passages
Chapter opening: Genesis 38:1-30
His Incest with Thamar - Genesis 38 The following sketch from the life of Judah is intended to point out the origin of the three leading families of the future princely tribe in Israel, and at the same time to show in what danger the sons of Jacob would have been of forgetting the sacred vocation of their race, through marriages with Canaanitish women, and of perishing in the sin of Canaan, if the mercy of God had not interposed, and by leading Joseph into Egypt prepared the way for the removal of the whole house of Jacob into that land, and thus protected the family, just as it was expanding into a nation, from the corrupting influence of the manners and customs of Canaan. This being the intention of the narrative, it is no episode or interpolation, but an integral part of the early history of Israel, which is woven here into the history of Jacob, because the events occurred subsequently to the sale of Joseph.
About this time, i. e. , after the sale of Joseph, while still feeding the flocks of Jacob along with his brethren (Gen 37:26), Judah separated from them, and went down (from Hebron, Gen 37:14, or the mountains) to Adullam, in the lowland (Jos 15:35), into the neighbourhood of a man named Hirah. “ He pitched (his tent, Gen 26:25) up to a man of Adullam, ” i.
e. , in his neighbourhood, so as to enter into friendly intercourse with him.
Gen 38:2-5 There Judah married the daughter of Shuah, a Canaanite, and had three sons by her: Ger (ער), Onan, and Shelah. The name of the place is mentioned when the last is born, viz., Chezib or Achzib (Jos 15:44; Mic 1:14), in the southern portion of the lowland of Judah, that the descendants of Shelah might know the birth-place of their ancestor. This was unnecessary in the case of the others, who died childless.
Gen 38:2-5 There Judah married the daughter of Shuah, a Canaanite, and had three sons by her: Ger (ער), Onan, and Shelah. The name of the place is mentioned when the last is born, viz., Chezib or Achzib (Jos 15:44; Mic 1:14), in the southern portion of the lowland of Judah, that the descendants of Shelah might know the birth-place of their ancestor. This was unnecessary in the case of the others, who died childless.
Gen 38:2-5 There Judah married the daughter of Shuah, a Canaanite, and had three sons by her: Ger (ער), Onan, and Shelah. The name of the place is mentioned when the last is born, viz., Chezib or Achzib (Jos 15:44; Mic 1:14), in the southern portion of the lowland of Judah, that the descendants of Shelah might know the birth-place of their ancestor. This was unnecessary in the case of the others, who died childless.
Gen 38:2-5 There Judah married the daughter of Shuah, a Canaanite, and had three sons by her: Ger (ער), Onan, and Shelah. The name of the place is mentioned when the last is born, viz., Chezib or Achzib (Jos 15:44; Mic 1:14), in the southern portion of the lowland of Judah, that the descendants of Shelah might know the birth-place of their ancestor. This was unnecessary in the case of the others, who died childless.
Gen 38:6-10 When Ger was grown up, according to ancient custom (cf. Gen 21:21; Gen 34:4) his father gave him a wife, named Thamar, probably a Canaanite, of unknown parentage. But Ger was soon put to death by Jehovah on account of his wickedness. Judah then wished Onan, as the brother-in-law, to marry the childless widow of his deceased brother, and raise up seed, i.
e. , a family, for him. But as he knew that the first-born son would not be the founder of his own family, but would perpetuate the family of the deceased and receive his inheritance, he prevented conception when consummating the marriage by spilling the semen. ארצה שׁחת, “destroyed to the ground (i. e. , let it fall upon the ground), so as not to give seed to his brother” (נתן for תּת only here and Num 20:21).
This act not only betrayed a want of affection to his brother, combined with a despicable covetousness for his possession and inheritance, but was also a sin against the divine institution of marriage and its object, and was therefore punished by Jehovah with sudden death. The custom of levirate marriage, which is first mentioned here, and is found in different forms among Indians, Persians, and other nations of Asia and Africa, was not founded upon a divine command, but upon an ancient tradition, originating probably in Chaldea.
It was not abolished, however, by the Mosaic law (Deu 25:5.) , but only so far restricted as not to allow it to interfere with the sanctity of marriage; and with this limitation it was enjoined as a duty of affection to build up the brother’s house, and to preserve his family and name (see my Bibl. Archäologie , §108).
Gen 38:6-10 When Ger was grown up, according to ancient custom (cf. Gen 21:21; Gen 34:4) his father gave him a wife, named Thamar, probably a Canaanite, of unknown parentage. But Ger was soon put to death by Jehovah on account of his wickedness. Judah then wished Onan, as the brother-in-law, to marry the childless widow of his deceased brother, and raise up seed, i.
e. , a family, for him. But as he knew that the first-born son would not be the founder of his own family, but would perpetuate the family of the deceased and receive his inheritance, he prevented conception when consummating the marriage by spilling the semen. ארצה שׁחת, “destroyed to the ground (i. e. , let it fall upon the ground), so as not to give seed to his brother” (נתן for תּת only here and Num 20:21).
This act not only betrayed a want of affection to his brother, combined with a despicable covetousness for his possession and inheritance, but was also a sin against the divine institution of marriage and its object, and was therefore punished by Jehovah with sudden death. The custom of levirate marriage, which is first mentioned here, and is found in different forms among Indians, Persians, and other nations of Asia and Africa, was not founded upon a divine command, but upon an ancient tradition, originating probably in Chaldea.
It was not abolished, however, by the Mosaic law (Deu 25:5.) , but only so far restricted as not to allow it to interfere with the sanctity of marriage; and with this limitation it was enjoined as a duty of affection to build up the brother’s house, and to preserve his family and name (see my Bibl. Archäologie , §108).
Gen 38:6-10 When Ger was grown up, according to ancient custom (cf. Gen 21:21; Gen 34:4) his father gave him a wife, named Thamar, probably a Canaanite, of unknown parentage. But Ger was soon put to death by Jehovah on account of his wickedness. Judah then wished Onan, as the brother-in-law, to marry the childless widow of his deceased brother, and raise up seed, i.
e. , a family, for him. But as he knew that the first-born son would not be the founder of his own family, but would perpetuate the family of the deceased and receive his inheritance, he prevented conception when consummating the marriage by spilling the semen. ארצה שׁחת, “destroyed to the ground (i. e. , let it fall upon the ground), so as not to give seed to his brother” (נתן for תּת only here and Num 20:21).
This act not only betrayed a want of affection to his brother, combined with a despicable covetousness for his possession and inheritance, but was also a sin against the divine institution of marriage and its object, and was therefore punished by Jehovah with sudden death. The custom of levirate marriage, which is first mentioned here, and is found in different forms among Indians, Persians, and other nations of Asia and Africa, was not founded upon a divine command, but upon an ancient tradition, originating probably in Chaldea.
It was not abolished, however, by the Mosaic law (Deu 25:5.) , but only so far restricted as not to allow it to interfere with the sanctity of marriage; and with this limitation it was enjoined as a duty of affection to build up the brother’s house, and to preserve his family and name (see my Bibl. Archäologie , §108).
Gen 38:6-10 When Ger was grown up, according to ancient custom (cf. Gen 21:21; Gen 34:4) his father gave him a wife, named Thamar, probably a Canaanite, of unknown parentage. But Ger was soon put to death by Jehovah on account of his wickedness. Judah then wished Onan, as the brother-in-law, to marry the childless widow of his deceased brother, and raise up seed, i.
e. , a family, for him. But as he knew that the first-born son would not be the founder of his own family, but would perpetuate the family of the deceased and receive his inheritance, he prevented conception when consummating the marriage by spilling the semen. ארצה שׁחת, “destroyed to the ground (i. e. , let it fall upon the ground), so as not to give seed to his brother” (נתן for תּת only here and Num 20:21).
This act not only betrayed a want of affection to his brother, combined with a despicable covetousness for his possession and inheritance, but was also a sin against the divine institution of marriage and its object, and was therefore punished by Jehovah with sudden death. The custom of levirate marriage, which is first mentioned here, and is found in different forms among Indians, Persians, and other nations of Asia and Africa, was not founded upon a divine command, but upon an ancient tradition, originating probably in Chaldea.
It was not abolished, however, by the Mosaic law (Deu 25:5.) , but only so far restricted as not to allow it to interfere with the sanctity of marriage; and with this limitation it was enjoined as a duty of affection to build up the brother’s house, and to preserve his family and name (see my Bibl. Archäologie , §108).
Gen 38:6-10 When Ger was grown up, according to ancient custom (cf. Gen 21:21; Gen 34:4) his father gave him a wife, named Thamar, probably a Canaanite, of unknown parentage. But Ger was soon put to death by Jehovah on account of his wickedness. Judah then wished Onan, as the brother-in-law, to marry the childless widow of his deceased brother, and raise up seed, i.
e. , a family, for him. But as he knew that the first-born son would not be the founder of his own family, but would perpetuate the family of the deceased and receive his inheritance, he prevented conception when consummating the marriage by spilling the semen. ארצה שׁחת, “destroyed to the ground (i. e. , let it fall upon the ground), so as not to give seed to his brother” (נתן for תּת only here and Num 20:21).
This act not only betrayed a want of affection to his brother, combined with a despicable covetousness for his possession and inheritance, but was also a sin against the divine institution of marriage and its object, and was therefore punished by Jehovah with sudden death. The custom of levirate marriage, which is first mentioned here, and is found in different forms among Indians, Persians, and other nations of Asia and Africa, was not founded upon a divine command, but upon an ancient tradition, originating probably in Chaldea.
It was not abolished, however, by the Mosaic law (Deu 25:5.) , but only so far restricted as not to allow it to interfere with the sanctity of marriage; and with this limitation it was enjoined as a duty of affection to build up the brother’s house, and to preserve his family and name (see my Bibl. Archäologie , §108).
Gen 38:11 The sudden death of his two sons so soon after their marriage with Thamar made Judah hesitate to give her the third as a husband also, thinking, very likely, according to a superstition which we find in Tobit 3:7ff. , that either she herself, or marriage with her, had been the cause of her husbands’ deaths. He therefore sent her away to her father’s house, with the promise that he would give her his youngest son as soon as he had grown up; though he never intended it seriously, “ for he thought lest (פּן אמר, i.
e. , he was afraid that) he also might die like his brethren . ” But when Thamar, after waiting a long time, saw that Shelah had grown up and yet was not given to her as a husband, she determined to procure children from Judah himself, who had become a widower in the meantime; and his going to Timnath to the sheep-shearing afforded her a good opportunity. The time mentioned (“the days multiplied,” i.
e. , a long time passed by) refers not to the statement which follows, that Judah’s wife died, but rather to the leading thought of the verse, viz. , Judah’s going to the sheep-shearing. ויּנּחם: he comforted himself, i. e. , he ceased to mourn. Timnath is not the border town of Dan and Judah between Beth-shemesh and Ekron in the plain (Jos 15:10; Jos 19:43), but Timnah on the mountains of Judah (Jos 15:57, cf.
Rob. Pal. ii. 343, note), as the expression “ went up ” shows. The sheep-shearing was a fête with shepherds, and was kept with great feasting. Judah therefore took his friend Hirah with him; a fact noticed in Gen 38:12 in relation to what follows.
Gen 38:13-14 As soon as Thamar heard of Judah’s going to this feast, she took off her widow’s clothes, put on a veil, and sat down, disguised as a harlot, by the gate of Enayim, where Judah would be sure to pass on his return from Timnath. Enayim was no doubt the same as Enam in the lowland of Judah (Jos 15:34).
Gen 38:13-14 As soon as Thamar heard of Judah’s going to this feast, she took off her widow’s clothes, put on a veil, and sat down, disguised as a harlot, by the gate of Enayim, where Judah would be sure to pass on his return from Timnath. Enayim was no doubt the same as Enam in the lowland of Judah (Jos 15:34).
Gen 38:15-18 When Judah saw her here and took her for a harlot, he made her an offer, and gave her his signet-ring, with the band (פּתיל) by which it was hung round his neck, and his staff, as a pledge of the young buck-goat which he offered her. They were both objects of value, and were regarded as ornaments in the East, as Herodotus (i. 195) has shown with regard to the Babylonians (see my Bibl. Arch . 2, 48). He then lay with her, and she became pregnant by him.
Gen 38:15-18 When Judah saw her here and took her for a harlot, he made her an offer, and gave her his signet-ring, with the band (פּתיל) by which it was hung round his neck, and his staff, as a pledge of the young buck-goat which he offered her. They were both objects of value, and were regarded as ornaments in the East, as Herodotus (i. 195) has shown with regard to the Babylonians (see my Bibl. Arch . 2, 48). He then lay with her, and she became pregnant by him.
Gen 38:15-18 When Judah saw her here and took her for a harlot, he made her an offer, and gave her his signet-ring, with the band (פּתיל) by which it was hung round his neck, and his staff, as a pledge of the young buck-goat which he offered her. They were both objects of value, and were regarded as ornaments in the East, as Herodotus (i. 195) has shown with regard to the Babylonians (see my Bibl. Arch . 2, 48). He then lay with her, and she became pregnant by him.
Gen 38:15-18 When Judah saw her here and took her for a harlot, he made her an offer, and gave her his signet-ring, with the band (פּתיל) by which it was hung round his neck, and his staff, as a pledge of the young buck-goat which he offered her. They were both objects of value, and were regarded as ornaments in the East, as Herodotus (i. 195) has shown with regard to the Babylonians (see my Bibl. Arch . 2, 48). He then lay with her, and she became pregnant by him.
Gen 38:19-21 After this had occurred, Thamar laid aside her veil, put on her widow’s dress again, and returned home. When Judah, therefore, sent the kid by his friend Hirah to the supposed harlot for the purpose of redeeming his pledges, he could not find her, and was told, on inquiring of the inhabitants of Enayim, that there was no קדשׁה there. הקּדשׁה: lit.
, “the consecrated,” i. e. , the hierodule , a woman sacred to Astarte, a goddess of the Canaanites, the deification of the generative and productive principle of nature; one who served this goddess by prostitution (vid. , Deu 23:18). This was no doubt regarded as the most respectable designation for public prostitutes in Canaan.
Gen 38:19-21 After this had occurred, Thamar laid aside her veil, put on her widow’s dress again, and returned home. When Judah, therefore, sent the kid by his friend Hirah to the supposed harlot for the purpose of redeeming his pledges, he could not find her, and was told, on inquiring of the inhabitants of Enayim, that there was no קדשׁה there. הקּדשׁה: lit.
, “the consecrated,” i. e. , the hierodule , a woman sacred to Astarte, a goddess of the Canaanites, the deification of the generative and productive principle of nature; one who served this goddess by prostitution (vid. , Deu 23:18). This was no doubt regarded as the most respectable designation for public prostitutes in Canaan.
Gen 38:19-21 After this had occurred, Thamar laid aside her veil, put on her widow’s dress again, and returned home. When Judah, therefore, sent the kid by his friend Hirah to the supposed harlot for the purpose of redeeming his pledges, he could not find her, and was told, on inquiring of the inhabitants of Enayim, that there was no קדשׁה there. הקּדשׁה: lit.
, “the consecrated,” i. e. , the hierodule , a woman sacred to Astarte, a goddess of the Canaanites, the deification of the generative and productive principle of nature; one who served this goddess by prostitution (vid. , Deu 23:18). This was no doubt regarded as the most respectable designation for public prostitutes in Canaan.
Gen 38:22-23 When his friend returned with the kid and reported his want of success, Judah resolved to leave his pledges with the girl, that he might not expose himself to the ridicule of the people by any further inquiries, since he had done his part towards keeping his promise. “ Let her take them (i.e., keep the signet-ring and staff) for herself, that we may not become a (an object of) ridicule .” The pledges were unquestionably of more value than a young he-goat.
Gen 38:22-23 When his friend returned with the kid and reported his want of success, Judah resolved to leave his pledges with the girl, that he might not expose himself to the ridicule of the people by any further inquiries, since he had done his part towards keeping his promise. “ Let her take them (i.e., keep the signet-ring and staff) for herself, that we may not become a (an object of) ridicule .” The pledges were unquestionably of more value than a young he-goat.
Gen 38:24-26 About three months afterwards (משׁלשׁ prob. for משּׁלשׁ with the prefix )מ Judah was informed that Thamar had played the harlot and was certainly (הנּה) with child. He immediately ordered, by virtue of his authority as head of the tribe, that she should be brought out and burned. Thamar was regarded as the affianced bride of Shelah, and was to be punished as a bride convicted of a breach of chastity.
But the Mosaic law enjoined stoning in the case of those who were affianced and broke their promise, or of newly married women who were found to have been dishonoured (Deu 22:20-21, Deu 22:23-24); and it was only in the case of the whoredom of a priest’s daughter, or of carnal intercourse with a mother or a daughter, that the punishment of burning was enjoined (Lev 21:9 and Lev 20:14). Judah’s sentence, therefore, was more harsh than the subsequent law; whether according to patriarchal custom, or on other grounds, cannot be determined.
When Thamar was brought out, she sent to Judah the things which she had kept as a pledge, with this message: “ By a man to whom these belong am I with child: look carefully therefore to whom this signet-ring, and band, and stick belong . ” Judah recognised the things as his own, and was obliged to confess, “ She is more in the right than I; for therefore (sc.
, that this might happen to me, or that it might turn out so; on כּי־על־כּן see Gen 18:5) have I not given her to my son Shelah . ” In passing sentence upon Thamar, Judah had condemned himself. His son, however, did not consist merely in his having given way to his lusts so afar as to lie with a supposed public prostitute of Canaan, but still more in the fact, that by breaking his promise to give her his son Shelah as her husband, he had caused his daughter-in-law to practise this deception upon him, just because in his heart he blamed her for the early and sudden deaths of his elder sons, whereas the real cause of the deaths which had so grieved his paternal heart was the wickedness of the sons themselves, the mainspring of which was to be found in his own marriage with a Canaanite in violation of the patriarchal call.
And even if the sons of Jacob were not unconditionally prohibited from marrying the daughters of Canaanites, Judah’s marriage at any rate had borne such fruit in his sons Ger and Onan, as Jehovah the covenant God was compelled to reject. But if Judah, instead of recognising the hand of the Lord in the sudden death of his sons, traced the cause to Thamar, and determined to keep her as a childless widow all her life long, not only in opposition to the traditional custom, but also in opposition to the will of God as expressed in His promises of a numerous increase of the seed of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob; Thamar had by no means acted rightly in the stratagem by which she frustrated his plan, and sought to procure from Judah himself the seed of which he was unjustly depriving her, though her act might be less criminal than Judah's.
For it is evident from the whole account, that she was not driven to her sin by lust, but by the innate desire for children (ὅτι δὲ παιδοποΐ́ιας χάριν, καὶ οὐ φιληδονίας τοῦτο ὁ Θάμαρ ἐμηχανήσατο, - Theodoret ); and for that reason she was more in the right than Judah. Judah himself, however, not only saw his guilt, but he confessed it also; and showed both by this confession, and also by the fact that he had no further conjugal intercourse with Thamar, an earnest endeavour to conquer the lusts of the flesh, and to guard against the sin into which he had fallen.
And because he thus humbled himself, God gave him grace, and not only exalted him to be the chief of the house of Israel, but blessed the children that were begotten in sin.
Gen 38:24-26 About three months afterwards (משׁלשׁ prob. for משּׁלשׁ with the prefix )מ Judah was informed that Thamar had played the harlot and was certainly (הנּה) with child. He immediately ordered, by virtue of his authority as head of the tribe, that she should be brought out and burned. Thamar was regarded as the affianced bride of Shelah, and was to be punished as a bride convicted of a breach of chastity.
But the Mosaic law enjoined stoning in the case of those who were affianced and broke their promise, or of newly married women who were found to have been dishonoured (Deu 22:20-21, Deu 22:23-24); and it was only in the case of the whoredom of a priest’s daughter, or of carnal intercourse with a mother or a daughter, that the punishment of burning was enjoined (Lev 21:9 and Lev 20:14). Judah’s sentence, therefore, was more harsh than the subsequent law; whether according to patriarchal custom, or on other grounds, cannot be determined.
When Thamar was brought out, she sent to Judah the things which she had kept as a pledge, with this message: “ By a man to whom these belong am I with child: look carefully therefore to whom this signet-ring, and band, and stick belong . ” Judah recognised the things as his own, and was obliged to confess, “ She is more in the right than I; for therefore (sc.
, that this might happen to me, or that it might turn out so; on כּי־על־כּן see Gen 18:5) have I not given her to my son Shelah . ” In passing sentence upon Thamar, Judah had condemned himself. His son, however, did not consist merely in his having given way to his lusts so afar as to lie with a supposed public prostitute of Canaan, but still more in the fact, that by breaking his promise to give her his son Shelah as her husband, he had caused his daughter-in-law to practise this deception upon him, just because in his heart he blamed her for the early and sudden deaths of his elder sons, whereas the real cause of the deaths which had so grieved his paternal heart was the wickedness of the sons themselves, the mainspring of which was to be found in his own marriage with a Canaanite in violation of the patriarchal call.
And even if the sons of Jacob were not unconditionally prohibited from marrying the daughters of Canaanites, Judah’s marriage at any rate had borne such fruit in his sons Ger and Onan, as Jehovah the covenant God was compelled to reject. But if Judah, instead of recognising the hand of the Lord in the sudden death of his sons, traced the cause to Thamar, and determined to keep her as a childless widow all her life long, not only in opposition to the traditional custom, but also in opposition to the will of God as expressed in His promises of a numerous increase of the seed of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob; Thamar had by no means acted rightly in the stratagem by which she frustrated his plan, and sought to procure from Judah himself the seed of which he was unjustly depriving her, though her act might be less criminal than Judah's.
For it is evident from the whole account, that she was not driven to her sin by lust, but by the innate desire for children (ὅτι δὲ παιδοποΐ́ιας χάριν, καὶ οὐ φιληδονίας τοῦτο ὁ Θάμαρ ἐμηχανήσατο, - Theodoret ); and for that reason she was more in the right than Judah. Judah himself, however, not only saw his guilt, but he confessed it also; and showed both by this confession, and also by the fact that he had no further conjugal intercourse with Thamar, an earnest endeavour to conquer the lusts of the flesh, and to guard against the sin into which he had fallen.
And because he thus humbled himself, God gave him grace, and not only exalted him to be the chief of the house of Israel, but blessed the children that were begotten in sin.
Gen 38:24-26 About three months afterwards (משׁלשׁ prob. for משּׁלשׁ with the prefix )מ Judah was informed that Thamar had played the harlot and was certainly (הנּה) with child. He immediately ordered, by virtue of his authority as head of the tribe, that she should be brought out and burned. Thamar was regarded as the affianced bride of Shelah, and was to be punished as a bride convicted of a breach of chastity.
But the Mosaic law enjoined stoning in the case of those who were affianced and broke their promise, or of newly married women who were found to have been dishonoured (Deu 22:20-21, Deu 22:23-24); and it was only in the case of the whoredom of a priest’s daughter, or of carnal intercourse with a mother or a daughter, that the punishment of burning was enjoined (Lev 21:9 and Lev 20:14). Judah’s sentence, therefore, was more harsh than the subsequent law; whether according to patriarchal custom, or on other grounds, cannot be determined.
When Thamar was brought out, she sent to Judah the things which she had kept as a pledge, with this message: “ By a man to whom these belong am I with child: look carefully therefore to whom this signet-ring, and band, and stick belong . ” Judah recognised the things as his own, and was obliged to confess, “ She is more in the right than I; for therefore (sc.
, that this might happen to me, or that it might turn out so; on כּי־על־כּן see Gen 18:5) have I not given her to my son Shelah . ” In passing sentence upon Thamar, Judah had condemned himself. His son, however, did not consist merely in his having given way to his lusts so afar as to lie with a supposed public prostitute of Canaan, but still more in the fact, that by breaking his promise to give her his son Shelah as her husband, he had caused his daughter-in-law to practise this deception upon him, just because in his heart he blamed her for the early and sudden deaths of his elder sons, whereas the real cause of the deaths which had so grieved his paternal heart was the wickedness of the sons themselves, the mainspring of which was to be found in his own marriage with a Canaanite in violation of the patriarchal call.
And even if the sons of Jacob were not unconditionally prohibited from marrying the daughters of Canaanites, Judah’s marriage at any rate had borne such fruit in his sons Ger and Onan, as Jehovah the covenant God was compelled to reject. But if Judah, instead of recognising the hand of the Lord in the sudden death of his sons, traced the cause to Thamar, and determined to keep her as a childless widow all her life long, not only in opposition to the traditional custom, but also in opposition to the will of God as expressed in His promises of a numerous increase of the seed of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob; Thamar had by no means acted rightly in the stratagem by which she frustrated his plan, and sought to procure from Judah himself the seed of which he was unjustly depriving her, though her act might be less criminal than Judah's.
For it is evident from the whole account, that she was not driven to her sin by lust, but by the innate desire for children (ὅτι δὲ παιδοποΐ́ιας χάριν, καὶ οὐ φιληδονίας τοῦτο ὁ Θάμαρ ἐμηχανήσατο, - Theodoret ); and for that reason she was more in the right than Judah. Judah himself, however, not only saw his guilt, but he confessed it also; and showed both by this confession, and also by the fact that he had no further conjugal intercourse with Thamar, an earnest endeavour to conquer the lusts of the flesh, and to guard against the sin into which he had fallen.
And because he thus humbled himself, God gave him grace, and not only exalted him to be the chief of the house of Israel, but blessed the children that were begotten in sin.
Gen 38:27-28 Thamar brought forth twins; and a circumstance occurred at the birth, which does occasionally happen when the children lie in an abnormal position, and always impedes the delivery, and which was regarded in this instance as so significant that the names of the children were founded upon the fact. At the birth ויּתּן־יד “ there was a hand, ” i.e., a hand came out (יתּן as in Job 37:10; Pro 13:10), round which the midwife tied a scarlet thread, to mark this as the first-born.
Gen 38:27-28 Thamar brought forth twins; and a circumstance occurred at the birth, which does occasionally happen when the children lie in an abnormal position, and always impedes the delivery, and which was regarded in this instance as so significant that the names of the children were founded upon the fact. At the birth ויּתּן־יד “ there was a hand, ” i.e., a hand came out (יתּן as in Job 37:10; Pro 13:10), round which the midwife tied a scarlet thread, to mark this as the first-born.
Gen 38:29-30 “ And it came to pass, when it (the child) drew back its hand (כּמשׁיב for משׁיב כּהיות as in Gen 40:10), behold its brother came out. Then she (the midwife) said, What a breach hast thou made for thy part? Upon thee the breach ;” i. e. , thou bearest the blame of the breach. פּרץ signifies not rupturam perinoei , but breaking through by pressing forward.
From that he received the name of Perez (breach, breaker through). Then the other one with the scarlet thread came into the world, and was named Zerah (זרח exit, rising), because he sought to appear first, whereas in fact Perez was the first-born, and is even placed before Zerah in the lists in Gen 46:12; Num 26:20. Perez was the ancestor of the tribe-prince Nahshon (Num 2:3), and of king David also (Rth 4:18.
; 1Ch 2:5.) Through him, therefore, Thamar has a place as one of the female ancestors in the genealogy of Jesus Christ.